My letter to Nick Alston, Essex PCC

I have written to Nick Alston, Police and Crime Commissioner for Essex, following an article in the Yellow Advertiser. Here is what I have written:


I am a little unsettled by a report in this week’s Southend Yellow Advertiser, which quotes PC Martin Knight. (All vagrants are either ‘druggies or alcoholics’)

Firstly I must put it on record that I consider the Police I encounter in my role as a Southend-on-Sea Borough councillor do an excellent job in difficult circumstances.

I take exception to this report, which seeks to label the homeless as all causing anti-social behaviour and crime.

The quotes in the article are some way from the reality I have seen. All rough sleepers do not have substance abuse issues, although I accept that many do. Whilst some choose the streets live on, the vast majority are there not through choice.

In my experience, albeit limited (and I do defer to experts, like Shelter) there are many reasons for homelessness. Some are poor, some lose their jobs, some are evicted from their homes. Divorce and separation figure amongst the reasons people are forced to sleep rough, as do mental health issues. Some are escaping abuse. It is a far from simple picture, and the glib explanation that all who are vagrant “choose to live on the streets and take drugs and drink alcohol” is misleading. It is also harmful.

Some of the homeless acquire substance issues because of being homeless – it is a symptom of their homelessness rather than the reason. Many rough sleepers encounter violence and articles like this, in my opinion, help legitimise this.

I do receive complaints from residents about begging and anti-social behaviour caused by some in the homeless community, and the Southend Police do a good job in dealing with this. I take a zero-tolerance approach to this. But to label all who are ‘vagrant’ in the way described by PC Knight is plain wrong.

I hope you will be able to tell me that the article misquotes Essex Police. I hope you can also assure me that the Police in Southend will continue to do the fine job in treating the homeless with respect that all deserve. Homelessness is a growing issue, and we should be looking for solutions rather than stigmatising the most vulnerable in our community.



About these ads

4 Responses to My letter to Nick Alston, Essex PCC

  1. Cheryl says:

    Hear, hear! I could not believe this article’s insensitivity. I will also write a letter of complaint. Julian, we have visited the night shelter, we both know some of the vulnerable people he speaks of are suffering with Mental Health conditions, some are battling addictions, which emanate from their vulnerable status and some are homeless through circumstance.
    The police are often caught in the middle dealing with social cases that society should provide a safety net for, but current government policy leaves it severely lacking, here I sympathise, but generalising in this way is dismissing the very real problem we have here in Southend, with poverty and overcrowding.
    If anyone said “All police officers are the same” I would leap to defend my very good friends who serve in the police force. Mr, Knight should come and visit the emergency night shelters in Southend where service users will tell you that all they want is a quiet life and to not be moved from one place to the next. Unfortunately, in our society, currently, we treat our stray dogs better than we treat our stray humans.

  2. Colin Gilbey says:

    Well put Julian. Unfortunately this apparently (semi) official is typical of the right wing state and society – blame the victim and do nothing about the cause.

  3. Pingback: I wanted a response, I got a response; reassurances about policing the homeless | Julian's musings

  4. Pingback: Misrepresented by the Southend Echo | Julian's musings

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 2,224 other followers

%d bloggers like this: